...
Setup stage:
*Doesn't see how to drag and drop art. confused as to lack of feedback in dialog. wonders why it doesn't show art, unclear how to advance. wonders why the upload link shows on the left
*Trouble finding next step button “customize critique”
*then, find back button “customize critique” confusing
...
Reviewing Feedback stage:
*overall rating very clear
*understand meaning of categories filters on the side
*satisfied to see annotation symbols on picture expand with comments
*satisfied with the exploration of previous versions by clicking
*did not try to explore the groups tabs at the top by herself, unsure what the effect of the tab may be ("would the default be all if there aren't multiple groups? I expected to see friends since this is the only group who I asked for feedback").
Host 5:
Setup stage:
first thing I would do is title it. upload picture. get replaced done
customize my critique
i would like both emotional and technical then next
"i would like only my mentors to see..." "what is other groups mean?". (after explanation) "I want these people not to see..." *unclean about the meaning of groups
Review feedback stage:
*use box filters to see a specific type of feedback
overall comments: how do I know from who. now I want to only see from mentor. ok. now what my colleagues said
what's unclear what an overall comment ?
what do my friend say? reminds me of will bring hyperlink in browser
I want to see last updated version
cool that's awesomeis.
*wondering at first who the comment is from.
Host 6:
(same as commenter 6)
Setup stage:
*setup progress: would like to have a progress bar in the bottom (i.e. "step 1 of 3") Also . Also a way to skip to the end.
*categories: not completely sure how to use these categories, may waht want to ask a specific type of feedback that does not fit under these, through an optional textbox
*group members: wondered who are the members of each groups (mentors, colleagues). Ideally would drop down list of email in each? Define your groups with a drop down?
*group public/private: not clear. Maybe "drag for public/private comments"
Review feedback stage:
Like the overall rating
bunch of comments I can scroll through on rate. I like it. Also filters.
expanding by clicking will scroll to that comment on the right and expand comment
if only check general. Have only general comments
looks like there are version. I want to see comments for old version. click on it. refresh the picture.
curious what mentors said about it. I see a rating and comments from mentors. version did not change. change the comments
confusing: if I mouse on annotation it also scrolls on the right, I lose my position. No need to double display, I don't want to lose my position if I scrolled somewhere on the right.
categories confusing.
versions I want *no learnability issue with scrolling through comments, with filtering the comment by categories, expanding them, finding comments from previous version
*efficiency/safety issue: if host mouse through annotation on picture, it scrolls to the corresponding comment on right, host loses their position, which is disturbing if they scrolled to a particular comment on the right. No need for this double display.
*versions: would like to know how the feedback compares.
...